Perfectionism and People-Pleasing in Relationships: How to Stop Sacrificing Your Needs for Others
Imagine this: You’ve had a long week, and all you want is a quiet evening to recharge. Instead, you’re saying "yes" to helping a family member with a task they could manage themselves—or agreeing to drinks with friends when you’re already drained—because saying "no" feels impossible. And while you’re busy trying to avoid disappointing anyone, you’re also stepping in to the role of “fixer,” making sure everything goes smoothly and that no detail slips through the cracks.
If you’re nodding along, you’re not alone. For many New Yorkers juggling busy careers, packed social calendars, and the pressures of living in a fast-paced city, perfectionism and people-pleasing can feel like double-edged swords. They might seem like a way to strengthen relationships or prove your worth, but they often leave you exhausted, disconnected, and questioning if anyone truly sees you.
Keep reading to explore why these patterns arise, how they affect your relationships, and actionable steps to reclaim your needs without sacrificing the connections you value. And if you're ready to dive even deeper and make a change, online therapy for perfectionism and people-pleasing in New York can be a powerful tool in helping you break free from these patterns. It can help you discover more authentic ways to connect with others while honoring your own needs.
The Weight of Trying to Be the “Perfect” Friend, Partner, or Family Member
You might be deeply empathetic and genuinely driven to connect with others, often wanting to support and help those around you. And while doing your best for others is a wonderful goal, it’s easy to take it too far. I often work with my clients in therapy for perfectionism to understand how perfectionism and people-pleasing often stem from a desire to feel accepted, avoid conflict, or protect yourself emotionally.
At their core, these tendencies may have started as survival strategies, helping you navigate relationships or challenging experiences. But over time, the constant striving to meet everyone’s needs—while ignoring your own—can take a toll. Online therapy for perfectionism in Queens & throughout New York offers tools to address how suppressing your feelings to prioritize others can make trust and closeness difficult to build. After all, if you don’t show your true self, it’s hard to believe you’re loved for who you are—or to trust others to be there for you when you need them.
Here's a breakdown of these patterns often affect relationships:
Your Focus Shifts: Instead of enjoying the relationship, you’re consumed with getting everything “just right” or taking on every possible task to make sure others are happy. You might feel pressure to be the one who always remembers birthdays, plans the perfect outing, or makes sure everyone gets along.
Connection Suffers: Vulnerability—the foundation of real connection—takes a backseat when you’re focused on avoiding mistakes or negative reactions. When we’re so focused on managing others’ perceptions, we miss opportunities for authentic connection, often losing sight of what we really need or want in our relationships.
You Burn Out: The cycle of doing more, giving more, and trying harder is exhausting. The higher your expectations of yourself, the more impossible they become to meet—and the more resentment and self-doubt creep in.
Pause and Reflect: What’s the cost of trying to be perfect? What are you sacrificing when you prioritize everyone else’s needs over your own?
How Perfectionism and People-Pleasing Show Up in Different Relationships
These tendencies don’t necessarily look the same in every relationship, but their effects can be just as draining in each one. Let’s take a closer look:
In Romantic Relationships
Early on in a relationship, you might find yourself overcompensating: planning every date, saying “yes” to everything, or bending over backward to make things work. While you’re busy fitting into their life, it’s easy to lose sight of whether they fit into yours.
In long-term relationships, taking on too much responsibility—like handling all the household tasks or always initiating plans—can create an unbalanced dynamic. By avoiding conflict or trying to make sure everything is perfect, you might unintentionally stifle opportunities for vulnerability and connection. Ironically, mistakes and healthy conflict can actually strengthen relationships by allowing deeper emotional expression and understanding.
Small Step: Practice expressing a simple need, like asking for help with dinner or sharing an honest feeling about your day.
In Friendships
Fear of rejection or falling short can lead to overcommitting: always planning activities, avoiding disagreements, or going overboard with gifts and gestures. While it might feel like you’re keeping the peace or acting out of selflessness, overcompensating can actually block deeper connection.
When you hold back or hide parts of yourself to keep things smooth, your friends don’t get to see the real you. Instead of building closeness, this version of you can leave you feeling misunderstood or like they don’t really get or accept you.
Small Step: Let someone else take the lead on planning or share an opinion you’d usually keep to yourself.
Related read: Creating Connection: Free Yourself from the Internal Pressure to Entertain
In Family Relationships
Even as adults, many of us still crave acceptance from our families—sometimes at the expense of our boundaries. You might suppress your feelings, take on extra responsibilities, or say “yes” to things that drain you to avoid conflict, maintain the “peace,” or meet high expectations.
But constantly prioritizing others in your family over yourself can leave you feeling unseen, unappreciated, and even resentful. True closeness can only happen when both sides are free to show up authentically—without fear of disapproval or judgment.
Small Step: Say “no” to something small, like skipping a family event or leaving early, or politely passing on mediating a sibling disagreement.
Tools for Balancing Connection and Self-Care
Notice the Patterns: Awareness is the first step. Pay attention to when and where perfectionism or people-pleasing show up in your relationships. Consider how these patterns affect your emotions, energy, and ability to connect authentically.
Start Small: While perfectionism might push you to overhaul everything at once, that can feel overwhelming and unsustainable. Instead, focus on building small, manageable habits. Start with one new skill in one relationship—maybe setting a single boundary or expressing a small need. Over time, these small changes can grow into bigger, lasting shifts.
Set Boundaries: Start with something manageable. Use “I” statements to assert your needs, and resist the urge to overexplain or justify. For example, you can simply say, “I need to take some time for myself,” without feeling the need to elaborate. Remember, you have the right to set boundaries without having the “perfect” reason.
(Related read: Mastering Boundary Setting: Handling Negative Reactions with Confidence and Grace)
Build Emotional Tolerance: Change often feels uncomfortable, but that’s a natural part of growth. When someone reacts negatively, notice the discomfort in your body, observe your thoughts, and remind yourself that discomfort doesn’t mean you’re wrong. Practice sitting with others’ reactions rather than immediately trying to fix or avoid them. Over time, you’ll build resilience and find it easier to handle these moments.
Practice Self-Compassion: Perfection isn’t the goal—progress is. Expect slip-ups, moments of doubt, and occasional backtracking. These are normal and don’t mean you’re failing. Reframe boundary-setting and self-care as acts of balance, not selfishness. You’re not replacing care for others; you’re learning to care for yourself too.
Breaking Free to Build Healthier, More Authentic Relationships
Letting go of perfectionism and people-pleasing takes work, but the reward is worth it: healthier, more authentic relationships where you feel seen, valued, and connected. Learning to care for yourself as much as you care for others isn’t selfish—it’s an essential part of building relationships that nature connection and well-being.
Taking the first step toward change might feel daunting, but it's possible with the right support. By exploring these patterns and finding ways to balance self-care with connection, you can create a life where you feel more in tune with yourself and those around you.
Looking for Extra Support? Therapy for Perfectionism and People-Pleasing in New York Can Help!
If you're struggling to balance caring for others with honoring your own needs, therapy can help you break free from perfectionism and people-pleasing patterns. As a Licensed Mental Health Counselor and an online therapist for perfectionism in New York, I offer personalized online therapy for perfectionism and people pleasing to help you build healthier, more authentic relationships. Reach out today to start your journey toward greater balance and connection.
Schedule a consultation with me
Learn more about me and my services
Create space for both connection and self-care—your well-being matters too!
Other Therapy Services at Balanced Connections Counseling
Perfectionism and people-pleasing often create patterns that feel impossible to escape, especially when they show up in relationships. As an online therapist for perfectionism in New York, I understand how these struggles intertwine with challenges like anxiety and burnout, making it difficult to prioritize your own needs. That’s why I offer more than Therapy for Perfectionism—I also provide Therapy for Anxiety, Therapy for Burnout, and Therapy for People-Pleasing to support you in navigating these complex dynamics. If you’re feeling overwhelmed by the pressure to meet others’ expectations while neglecting your own, I’m here to help. Together, we can create a space where you feel empowered to set boundaries, embrace imperfection, and build more fulfilling, authentic relationships. This is your opportunity to release the weight of others’ expectations, reconnect with your needs, and rediscover joy in being yourself.